M.S. Dhoni: Master of Records but still to pass the test

5
1,760 views

“Facts are ventriloquist’s dummies. Sitting on a wise man’s knee they may be made to utter words of wisdom; elsewhere, they say nothing, or talk nonsense, or indulge in sheer diabolism.” Despite this warning, one cannot speak cricket without relying on statistics. Cricket journalism days of Neville Cardus or even Peter Roebuck are gone; the beauty of the game has lost its way in the bulk of numbers. World cricket has seen emergence of effective cricketers in the era of sheer professionalism; MSD is a by-product of this genre of cricket. Gifted with numbers which can be used to compare with some of the greatest cricket heroes of all time, MS Dhoni has become successful in becoming the demi-god of world’s largest cricket playing nation. If you go by mere facts, Dhoni has indeed achieved numerous extraordinary feats.

Highest ODI score by a wicket-keeper batsman:

A young MS, with his out-of-cricket-book helicopter shot in his arsenal, scored a handy 183* against Sri Lanka in 145 balls and wrote the script of a comfortable win. His innings is still the highest by a wicket-keeper, followed by Gilchrist’s 172 against Zimbabwe and Sangakkara’s 169 against South Africa. Mesmerised by the spark of that innings, Indians still overlook the fact that it took 2 years for MSD to bag another ton.

en route to his 183* against Sri Lanka
en route to his 183* against Sri Lanka

Most stumpings in international cricket:

As soon as the Indian skipper stumped Alastair Cook at Trent Bridge a few days ago, he became the keeper with most stumpings, taking all three formats into account. Currently, he holds the record with 131 stumpings. His Sri Lankan counterpart Sangakkara is closely behind. The comparison between the two is given below.

dhonisanga
(till 2nd September, 2014)

India’s best captain in ODI: (Or one should say, highest winning percentage?)

Along with Mohammad Azharuddin, MS holds the most number of wins as an Indian captain. Both of them won 90 matches, while Dhoni took 161 matches as compared to Azhar’s 174 matches. With still a few years left on his career, Dhoni should feel comfortable that this record cannot be broken in near future. Moreover, he has laid his hands in the well-deserved ICC World Cup trophy which has lifted his success to a whole new level.

Md. Azharuddin was statistically the best Indian captain until yesterday
Md. Azharuddin was statistically the best Indian captain until yesterday

May be he is effective in colored jersey formats of cricket, he can be the best finisher of the game, or what is more vital that he has a winning luck, but all these never justify why he can be considered a great cricketer in classical sense or why he should not be dropped from the test cricket after the bitter performances in foreign soil, his individual overseas average happens to be below 30. Though under his captaincy India has touched the no1 spot in ICC test and ODI rankings and has won 2 world cups, but that cannot be the reason why he should be allowed to continue captaining India for some indefinite period of time. MSD has some serious issue with his technique and temperament. In some recent test matches, it is seen that he tries to be more conservative and plays excessive defensive shots early in his innings which is not his style. Finally, after scoring only a few runs, he loses his patience and succumbs to some easy delivery.

Does this mean MSD is a less talented cricketer? No. What it shows is that he is basically overachieving. Protected by a battalion of numbers, records as well as IPL, and being overhyped by the mass, his lack of skills in batting technique and inability to create a symphony with the bat will remain overshadowed; but as long as you can be effective- who cares!

5 COMMENTS

  1. Forget the captaincy…Did you see the record of the previous wicket keepers India had, They were not even called batsman…Ajay ratra…MS Prasad …..Parthiv Patel the list goes long…I think I remember him as the only wicket keeper BATSMAN of India after following the game foe almost 20 years….

  2. […] A man born to break records with ease, Dhoni has the world record of longest unbeaten run in tests (11) from his debut. He captained the country in 60 tests and India won 27 of them, highest ever by an Indian captain. He also took Team India to the zenith when India became number 1 in Tests under his leadership. Among other records, during Dhoni-era, India reached their highest ever innings total (726 against Sri Lanka), recorded their biggest ever win in terms of runs (320 against Australia) and had an amazing record of remaining unbeaten in 90% of the tests at home. […]

LEAVE A REPLY